12 November 2024

Failed experiments | Hiatus - Weekly briefing - November 12, 2024

Essential human-curated Florida Keys news, all in one place. 

Subscribe to Key West Voices for free. See something that should be in Voices? Click here to share it with us.

Our Community


Failed experiments. For the near entirety of known human existence, individuals have had little or no say in choosing those who make life and death decisions for them. Then, the so-called "American Experiment" arrived with the well-intentioned and novel ideal that the choice of leaders should be in the hands of those led rather than by use of force or parentage. Although far from perfect, the American Experiment demonstrated the potential for societal evolution aimed at ensuring basic rights and opportunities for all. Some nations emulated the ideal, as imperfectly as our own example. And while admirable progress was made, much work remained, and success was never guaranteed. 

We now begin the era of American Fascism, which despite the ineptitude of its leaders, will likely inflict irreparable, if not fatal harm to the experiment. We have regressed to the norm of human existence. The ideal of America may not be dead, but it is on life support, and under the care of those who would gleefully hasten its end. 

Key West Voices was born of a group of community minded residents in an Old Town backyard in the spring of 2023, with the intent to bring vital news and opinion from multiple sources to those who might not otherwise engage with it. Anticipating the local elections now just past, the hypothesis was that a better informed electorate could slow the relentless march of commerce, greed, and exploitation that are no less a threat to our beloved Keys than sea level rise, and changing our lives far more quickly. But all the candidates who represented thoughtful restraint lost to those who will accelerate our surrender. The experiment that was KWV failed too.  

As a news junkie, your curator would normally read about a thousand headlines a week to pluck out the dozen or so mostly local stories that were essential and relevant in order to share them with you here. While the number of KWV subscribers increased steadily but slowly, we never reached the critical mass that might have had an effect on the election outcome. And we never attracted other curators to elaborate and evolve the purpose of this modest publication. 

I plucked no headlines this week, and barely had the stomach to even read them. I don't expect my appetite to improve anytime soon. So in the absence of its founding sense of purpose, I've arrived at the decision to put KWV on hiatus. And while the subscriber list and technology mechanisms to publish remain in place, this is the last issue of KWV you'll likely see for the foreseeable future. 

I'm grateful for those who've subscribed, read, and occasionally commented on what was done here. I will personally and confidentially respond to any thoughts you'd like to share by email at keywestvoices@gmail.com


Our Eyes


A hermit crab on Garden Key - 11-10-24 - Phil Dodderidge

- 30 - 

06 November 2024

GOP sweep in Monroe - Special election edition - November 6, 2024

Essential human-curated Florida Keys news, all in one place. 

Subscribe to Key West Voices for free. See something that should be in Voices? Click here to share it with us.

Our Community

Unofficial election results. Official results only at https://www.keyselections.org/ 
  • POTUS - Trump defeats Harris
  • U.S. Senate - Scott defeats Mucarsel-Powell
  • Amendment # - Legal marijuana - defeated
  • Amendment # - Abortion rights - defeated
  • Supervisor of Elections - Hodies defeats Saunders
  • County commission - Scholl defeats Massicotte
  • KW commission * - Castillo defeats Rose
Republican (or supported by party)
Democrat (or supported by party)

* non-partisan race

# Monroe County voted in favor of both marijuana and abortion referenda in excess of 60%.
 

05 November 2024

Vote | Rafael - Weekly briefing - November 5, 2024

Essential human-curated Florida Keys news, all in one place. 

Subscribe to Key West Voices for free. See something that should be in Voices? Click here to share it with us.

KWV regrets its error in the October 22 issue suggesting community opposition to the KW referendum to accept property from the county adjacent to the MLK pool. No such opposition exists.

Our Community


Storm watch.
 Tropical storm Rafael formed in the far southern Caribbean and is expected to reach hurricane strength by Tuesday evening near the Cayman Islands, according to the National Hurricane Center. A Tropical Storm watch is in effect for Lower and Middle Florida Keys from Key West to west of the Channel 5 Bridge.

Vote. Seriously, please vote. Today is election day. KWV readers are encouraged to return their vote by mail ballots or vote in person at their usual polling place, which may at a different location than the last time you voted. The Supervisor of Elections web site has a handy tool to help you locate your polling place.
  • Key local races to be decided. 
  • Who’s to blame? It may be us.  In a rare editorial addressing local politics, the Citizen connected recent scandals involving drug theft in Monroe County's Trauma Star emergency medical evacuation service, and audit failures with Monroe's Tourist Development Council (TDC), (both of which led to indictments) with inadequate voter participation and engagement. It chided (emphasis added):

    "The voters of Monroe County are often responsible for placing individuals in high-ranking positions, with those persons making decisions for the good of the county. As has been the case in recent years, many merely vote along party lines, regardless of the qualifications, experience and positions of the candidates.

    In numerous races this season, candidates did not even face competition, automatically assuming their posts. Most were incumbents, but others were new to their positions or, in one case, new to the political arena. What is holding back potential candidates?

    Democracy requires participation, but when participation is limited to one set of individuals or groups that wear blinders, the result is decision-making like a racehorse that simply goes to where the jockey directs it.

    The racehorse in Monroe County are the commissioners, and they were directed by a county administrator who led by putting blinders on them. As we approach the November election, voters must remember that our system of democracy works better when we have the requisite checks and balances.

    (Today) every eligible voter must get out and vote, but remember that it is not in our best interest to have all the power in the hands of a single party."
Two Oceans set adrift. The TDC board canceled its contract with Two Oceans Digital, the company that manages the Keys’ taxpayer supported official tourism website.
  • Overpaying. The move was recommended by a county audit of Two Oceans’ contract with the TDC, which revealed that the TDC was significantly overpaying for website and digital services given the payment structure of the contract. 
  • Outdated and lopsided. The county clerk’s audit of TDC’s contract with Two Oceans found an outdated and lopsided payment structure in which Two Oceans kept all ad revenue from the TDC’s website.
  • Massicotte objects. Democrat Chris Massicotte, who is challenging Republican incumbent Jim Scholl for the only remaining contested seat on the county commission, decried "a larger culture of complacency and a lack of oversight. When checks, balances, and transparency are missing, it costs us all. Thirty years is far too long for any company to hold a contract without review, and it’s unacceptable that there’s been no accountability."
Voters to decide on $226 million for improvements. Key West residents are voting on whether to allow the City of Key West to issue up to $226 million in general obligation bonds in the next 30 years for parks and recreation, transportation, police and fire and climate change adaption projects. The bonds are simply a line of credit that allows the Key West City Commission to individually consider and approve a variety of project proposals. More information is on a dedicated page the City's web site

Resigned, but feeling good. Linda Cunningham caught us up on topics including the election, TDC, Fantasy Fest, and looking forward to the end of hurricane season.

Please read 'Dear Connor.' Linda Cunningham wrote that "Dear Connor” is a collection of essays written for Connor Cunningham by his grandmother, Linda Grist Cunningham. I began writing these as my construct for making sense of the unraveling American community. Connor may never read them, nor might others; but they’ll help me distill solutions from the cacophony that passes for discourse in final crisis generational turning of America." This is Linda at her best. Well worth ten minutes instead of doomscrolling. 

Our Eyes  


Good Morning - Alyson Crean

Previously in Key West Voices


Not really news. Fantasy Fest took place without incident. After several days of zero storm activity, the National Hurricane Center is monitoring a (so far) non-threatening disturbance in the southern Caribbean east of Panama. Daylight savings time ends early Sunday morning, November 3rd.

Elections. Critical national, state-wide, regional, and local races and issues will be decided on November 5th.
  • Vote now! Readers are encouraged to return their vote by mail (VBM) ballots, early vote (EV), or make a plan to vote on election day, Tuesday, November 5th. Statewide and Monroe County VBM and EV can be tracked here daily

  • VBM surge
    • As of October 27, 11,029 mail ballots had been returned in Monroe County, while 6,076  ballots remain outstanding. 
    • VBM voters can save on postage by dropping their ballots in secured and guarded boxes at five locations across the Keys.  

  • EV enthusiasm. 
    • As of October 27, 8,292 citizens had voted early in Monroe County. One KWV contributor reported having to wait in line to early vote, for the first time in memory. 
    • EV continues daily at five locations across the Keys through Saturday, November 2. Note that the Key West residents' closest EV location is on College Road on Stock Island, and that the former location at Southard and Whitehead is no longer in use for early voting. Details at the Supervisor of Elections web site

  • KWCC District VI. The Citizen profiled the two candidates for the remaining contested seat on the Key West City Commission (KWCC), Aaron Castillo and Marci Rose. Although the race is non-partisan, Castillo has been endorsed by the Monroe County Republican party, and Rose by the Monroe County Democratic party. 
    • Rose said,  "As an attorney with over 30 years of experience, I’ve successfully settled 99% of my cases through negotiation. I know how to find common ground and achieve the best outcomes for everyone. If elected, I’ll stand firm on important issues for my constituents, even when outnumbered, but I also understand that progress often comes in small steps rather than all at once."
    • Castillo said,"I think everyone that knows me knows that I have a positive attitude and try to bring peace and joy to everyone around me. As a funeral director for the past 40 years, I have had to help people at the most difficult times of their lives. I think my positive attitude, good listening skills, open-mindedness and empathy, all of which I must do as a funeral director, will help to unite the commission."
    • Big money race Castillo's campaign has been heavily financed by business and tourism interests, some of which are from out of state. Key West Voices earlier ran a deep dive into Castillo's financing. Rose campaign is financed by small, local donations. 

  • BOCC District 3. The Citizen then profiled the two candidates for the only contested seat on Monroe's Board of County Commissioners (BOCC); incumbent Republican Jim Scholl and Democratic challenger Chris Massicotte
    • Massicotte's campaign raises questions about county government spending and accountability, especially in the wake of the critical audits of the county’s Tourist Development Council (TDC) and the grand jury indictments of former County Administrator Roman Gastesi and three others. The BOCC's "lack of oversight and accountability allowed corruption to fester at the highest levels," Massicotte said. 
    • Scholl said the BOCC "must be audit-ready, inspection-ready and investigation-ready every day... and that he trusts the county administrator for managing the staff. The county commission found out the audit results along with our citizens. Appropriate immediate administrative action took place to deal with staff. Further legal due process will continue and further action will follow the outcome of the legal processes."
    • Yet another bad news TDC audit. The BOCC received the fourth and final audit of the TDC which was harshly critical of its contract with its web site developer Two Oceans Digital. The results were "very troubling," said Kara Franker, the new president and CEO of the TDC.
    • ROGOs requested. Despite fierce opposition from community groups, the BOCC voted unanimously to request 220 additional residential building permits (ROGOs) from the state, the maximum allowed under restrictions due to the Keys' designation as an area of critical state concern. Keys Weekly's coverage provided a comprehensive, yet concise overview of the critical and controversial ROGO issues.  
    • Yet another poorly designed ROGO survey. The BOCC has fielded its fifth and final community surveythe design of which apparently promotes a pro-development agenda.  

  • Supervisor of Elections  The Citizen also profiled the two candidates for Supervisor of Elections (SOE). Republican Sherri Hodies and Democrat Ron Saunders are contending for the SOE job being vacated by the retiring Joyce Griffin.
  • KW property acquisition. In addition to four referenda seeking authority to issue general revenue bonds, the KWCC has placed two referenda related to property acquisition on the ballot. One seeks to change the city charter's rules for property acquisition to no longer require voter approval for certain types of property. 

  • School funding. Two school referendum items are on all ballots in Monroe County. They're the "least controversial items on the November ballot, but they will have the greatest impact on our local communities,” said school board chair Sue Woltanski. "...they simply ask to continue our current school funding, something our community has approved for the last 20 years."
Everyone needs a porch. Linda Cunningham loves and celebrated our porches

A sharpie is a sharp-shinned hawk. Mark Hedden translated otherwise impenetrable birder lingo heard at his latest hawkwatch.